Telegram Responses to Russ Wangersky Novermer 2007
Ire and the Irish connection
There’s a slogan for you — ‘Newfoundland and Labrador: almost as Irish as Syracuse.’
RUSSELL WANGERSKY
The Telegram
Enough of this Irish shtick, already. For years now, this province has been talking up its great and long-running ties to Ireland, that once-unsurpassed economic tiger of the European Union.
Now, anyone can understand wanting to hitch your wagon to a winner — and Ireland has been an economic winner for the last few years. The only problem is that our ties to the Emerald Isle are nowhere as great as we pretend they are. And the fact is that we probably are doing ourselves a disservice — and selling ourselves short — by pretending that they are.
It’s easy to cheer for winners.
Hey, almost everyone’s a Red Sox fan when they’re cruising towards a World Series win. But it was only the hard-core fans back in the 1970s and ’80s when Carl Yastrzemski was playing. He was from Irish Boston, by the way — but he wasn’t Irish.
The funny thing is, Boston’s every bit as Irish as we are.
Boston’s an interesting study. According to the 2006 U.S. census, 103,660 people in Boston, some 18 per cent of the area’s population, claim Irish ancestry — meaning, in case you were wondering, that there are more people of Irish descent in Boston alone than there are in the entire province of Newfoundland and Labrador (100,260).
Heck, there are more people of Irish descent in Montreal — 161,235 — than there are in this province, and almost five times as many people of Irish descent — 487,210 — in Toronto.
There are almost as many people of Irish descent in Halifax as there are in this province. Heck, Memphis has more people of Irish descent than we do.
Proportionally, we don’t do much better. With more than 1.5 million people of Irish descent, Massachusetts is 24 per cent Irish. We’re only approximately as Irish as Delaware.
There are 12 times as many people of Irish descent in the city of Philadelphia, Penn., alone as there are in this province — and a greater proportion of Irish, too. Think about this: 22 per cent of Philadelphians say they are of Irish descent. Pittsburgh? It’s proportionally as Irish as this province, yet with almost five times as many people of Irish descent. Even Kingston, N.Y. has 21 per cent.
At least one American census area that’s close to the size of our province, Syracuse, N.Y., has more people of Irish descent than we do — 143,562 — and a higher percentage, 22 per cent. There’s a slogan for you — “Newfoundland and Labrador: almost as Irish as Syracuse.”
But the problems with endlessly comparing ourselves to Ireland don’t end there.
Ireland has a history of being an agrarian country, while Newfoundland and Labrador has depended primarily on the fishery. Ireland is a small country of interconnected towns with a tremendous amount of agriculturally developed land. We are a province with a history of isolated towns surrounded by a tremendous amount of completely undeveloped land.
Our new money is in oil — theirs is in high tech.
But wait, you say: we’re both islands. Well, no, we’re not, not unless you want to have that Labrador part — you know, the one with all the resources — become its own pro-vince.
Why take my word for it? Meet a visitor here from Ireland, and they’ll tell you candidly we’re nothing like the Emerald Isle, and they don’t even understand why we’re reaching for the comparison.
And that brings me to a different but related point.
Why do we need to assume someone else’s brand anyway?
Why do we have to be the proto-Irish, or the proto-anything, for that matter?
There’s a tonne to be proud of in this province.
We’re from a vast range of different places — 40 per cent English, by the way, although politicians don’t go around promoting our cultural links to Olde England — and we’re united in having a history of surviving hardship and beating the odds in a harsh land.
Why should we be trumpeting our Irish heritage so much, instead of recognizing the 80 per cent of
Newfoundlanders and Labradorians whose heritage is quite different? There are plenty of people in this province who feel both offended and slighted by the fact they feel their heritage is being discounted by the pell-mell charge towards a sort of universal Irishness.
Let’s take time to be proud of who we are.
Top of the morning to you.
Comments
Boston Irish Tourism Association
I read Mr. Wangersky’s tongue-in-cheek article, which came up on our daily Google search of news relating Boston, Irish and tourism.
Having just met with delegates from Newfoundland who visited Boston last month to promote the island, I hope I can weigh in please.
The fact that Newfoundland isn’t 100% Irish ancestry is hardly the point when it comes to enticing people to visit your lovely island. Today’s global tourism industry is all about niche marketing – providing a series of travel options that appeal to various sectors.
That’s what your delegation did admirably by coming down here and connecting with New England’s large Irish-American community, which accounts for nearly 20% of the region, and inviting them to visit. Newfoundland’s Irish heritage was certainly touted – along with its stunning beauty, peacefulness, affordability, variety of culinary and musical festivities, and the friendliness of the people.
I can attest to the validity of this niche marketing approach, since that is what our group - the Boston Irish Tourism Association (BITA) – has been doing for Massachusetts since 2000.
We market the state’s Irish cultural community year round to the travel industry, by targeting tourists interested in Irish/Celtic culture. But that is only the hook, if you will. We also suggest to visitors where to stay, where to eat, what airlines fly here, seasonal outdoor activities, beaches, etc.
By branding Massachusetts as a particularly Irish destination in America, we don’t preclude or diminish any of the other fine ethnic groups working to bring tourism dollars to the state, in fact, we’re often asked to promote Scottish activities, since the two cultures are closely entwined.
Our number one goal is to entice tourists to visit, and we’re well aware that once they’re here, they’ll do much more than simply attend Irish festivals and parades. They'll contribute to our economy, which should be the goal of any tourism undertaking.
I invite your readers to visit our web site at www.IrishMassachusetts.com and see for yourself how our niche marketing works.
We also publish three issues of a tourism magazine a year – BITA’s Irish Travel & Culture – which highlights the 100+ members in our group – hotels, gift shops, pubs and restaurants, travel agencies, concert venues and of course cultural activities. I would be glad to send a copy of this publication to anyone who writes me.
The current Guide includes a profile on I-Dance, the Irish dance group in Newfoundland, and the Flying Boat Festival in Newfoundland next summer. That story came as a direct result of Newfoundlanders coming down here and making their product known!
You’ll also see stories in this issue on Prince Edward Island Tourism and Quebec City Tourism, which are both members of our organization. Those tourism agencies have been promoting their respective Irish communities in Massachusetts for several years, and have built a presence in this market.
Sincerely,
Michael P. Quinlin
President
Irish Cultural Centre of New England
After giving Mr. Wangersky's article some thought I would like to share his views from a different perspective.
Echoing what Mr. Quinlan, President of Boston Irish Tourism has said, Cultural Tourism is a very important way to increase the local economy. From what Mr. Wangersky said and using his numbers there is a potential of exposing and informing an additional 1,953,758 people in our regions in the US and eastern seaboard about the Heritage and Culture that has been left by Irish Ancestors.
This can be done by cultural organizations coming together to share their mutual connections and share how their respective communities have been shaped and influenced. It is not to say that the Irish Culture is the only culture. I, for one, share Polish in my ancestral background, but Irish is a common thread that all of the 1,953,758 of us in eastern USA share. I am a probably a good example of what Mr. Wangersky was referring to when he sites the 103,660 citizens of Irish Ancestry in Boston. I am second generation, my grandparents on my paternal side were born in County Donegal, in a rural fishing village in Innishowen. As Mr. Wangersky describes the physical features of Newfoundland, I found myself thinking of the similarities of where my grandparents grew up - a place I visit as often as I can.
Honestly I did not give Newfoundland and Labrador much thought in regards to a shared common Irish Ancestry. This was until Shawn Silver from iDance International met with our organization recently. This was not to say that I did not realize the Celtic influence in the Atlantic Provinces, just that Nova Scotia is the area primarily promoted in Boston. I am fortunate in my profession, as the Executive Director of the Irish Cultural Centre of New England, that I am able to promote and share this culture and heritage with others. In my capacity as Executive Director I am looking to inform my members, now totaling close to 4,000 new places that they might want to explore and discover the influences the Irish have had on other communities. I had recently looked to create a “Celtic Corridor” with our neighbors to the North. With Shawn Silver’s visit and willingness to explore this partnership I am looking forward to not only visiting but telling my members about a great destination to go to the North and it does not involve a long expensive plane ride. I hope Mr. Wangersky understands that being Irish or not, we are drawn to people and places that share our common ancestry. And we WANT to visit. I am sure the citizens of Newfoundland will be much more welcoming.
Sean Grant
Executive Director
Irish Cultural Centre of New England (ICCNE)
200 New Boston Drive
Canton, MA 02021
Irish Business Partnerships
Kristy Clarke from Dublin, Ireland writes: As a Newfoundlander of English ancestry, living in Ireland, I find Russell Wangersky’s views of the Ireland-Newfoundland connection unfortunate. He has only touched upon a small aspect of the shared interests of Ireland and Newfoundland, and has done so with inaccurate statistics. The portion of Newfoundlanders who can trace a family lineage to Ireland hovers closer to 50%, according to Newfoundland historian Dr. John Mannion and the Historical Atlas of Canada.
Irrespective, it is not about numbers. How can you compare any Newfoundland ethnicity by quantity to an ethnicity of Boston or New York? The Irish story in Newfoundland is about concentration, isolation and preservation. The Irish who came to Newfoundland (prior to the massive famine migrations that assimilated into America) formed small out port communities on the Avalon Southern shore, Fogo Island, the Northern Peninsula, etc, which were cut off from influence from other ethnicities. Their Southeast Ireland roots were left unaltered.
In today’s Ireland, a Newfoundlander of Irish-roots can still be mistaken as being from West Cork or Wexford. When you walk about Waterford or Kilkenny, or Dublin for that matter, you will see Irish faces that resemble the faces of friends and family in Newfoundland. I imagine in England’s Devon and Cornwall you would have similar chances of seeing familiar faces.
But why does it matter how many Newfoundlanders can trace a half dozen or more generations back to Ireland or England? There is no disputing that both cultures have played a role in Newfoundland’s thriving self-defined culture.
Ireland, however, has taken a keen interest in Newfoundland. The Irish government has a unit in its Department of the Prime Minister dedicated to promoting Newfoundland to the Irish. There is no other country offering such an honour and opportunity to Newfoundland. Its time for Newfoundlanders to recognize that the Irish, after turning around their social and economic misfortunes, now want to share their new knowledge with Irish communities abroad.
The Irish do have a lot to share with Newfoundland. Premier Danny Williams and past Premier Brian Tobin have recognized that Newfoundlanders should not pass over this prospect. Ireland and Newfoundland can share best practices in rural development, advanced technologies, ocean management, tourism and commercialization of culture. Both regions have economies on the fringe of the larger European and North American economies. Both share North Atlantic marine industries. Both have experienced large outmigration of their youth population. Both have rich musical, written and visual arts cultures that can have economic spinoffs. Both have strong post-secondary educational institutions and research facilities. There are many common interests where the two jurisdictions can grow from the other’s experience.
I strongly believe that Newfoundland has much to gain from Ireland, and vice-versa. I agree that we also have much to gain from our Alberta-bound post-secondary graduates, our English heritage, and the neighbouring American Eastern Seaboard economy. But it is important to diversify our interests and Ireland has opened its door. Lets put politics and history aside and seize the opportunity that Ireland has presented us.
Kristy Clarke
Ireland Newfoundland Partnership
Dublin, Ireland